Skip to content

Share :

Facebook
Email
LinkedIn

EXPRESS Singing Blog · Podcast

Opera vs. Musical Theatre: What’s the Difference for Singers?

Alyssa Curto is a mezzo-soprano and musical theatre performer who trained in opera at the University of Toronto (BMus) and the University of Ottawa (MMus). Her stage credits include Disney’s Frozen at Theatre Aquarius, Nicola in Kinky Boots, Irene Roth in Crazy for You and Allison in Beehive: The ’60s Musical with Drayton Entertainment, and Mina in Dracula at Victoria Playhouse Petrolia. In this episode of the Singers Tension Podcast, she talks with host Jordanne Erichsen, soprano and founder of EXPRESS Voice Studio, where working artists teach private singing lessons in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver. The two did their master’s degrees in opera together.

The short answer: opera and musical theatre differ in far more than sound. Opera is sung unamplified over an orchestra and trains one classical voice. Musical theatre is miked, covers every genre from pop to rock, and asks for scene work, dance and the stamina for eight shows a week. The training cultures, the auditions and the way singers are cast are different too. Read this guide, or press play to hear the whole conversation.

Jordanne Erichsen, founder of EXPRESS Voice Studio and host of the Singers Tension Podcast
Jordanne Erichsen, soprano, Alexander Technique practitioner, EXPRESS founder and host of the Singers Tension Podcast.
Listen: Singers Tension Podcast, Season 1, Episode 3 (60 min). Also on Spotify.

Want to sing opera, musical theatre or both? Book a lesson with an EXPRESS coach, in person or online.

How This Article Was Written

This article was conceptualized with the help of AI and built from the transcript of Singers Tension Podcast Season 1, Episode 3, recorded in 2020. It is written and reviewed by the EXPRESS team. Quotes are lightly edited for readability. Some personal parts of the conversation are summarized in general terms here, and the transcript at the bottom of this page leaves that portion out; the complete conversation is in the episode itself.

Article Takeaways

Musical theatre covers every genre, from pop and rock to classical, so versatility matters as much as one beautiful sound.

Classical training and belting can support each other. Alyssa says her classical training is what led her to her belt.

Know your own voice. Teachers, conductors and directors will disagree about it, and you are the one who lives in your body.

Opera vs. Musical Theatre: The Biggest Differences

Jordanne opens the episode by questioning an assumption many classical singers carry: that opera is the harder art form. Opera has to be heard over a large orchestra with no microphone, and building that voice takes years. Musical theatre is miked, so performers can play with intensity, emotion and colour in different ways, but it asks for acting as nuanced as a stage actor’s and for belting that holds up night after night.

Asked for the single biggest difference, Alyssa points to the range inside musical theatre itself. There are musicals based on pop, musicals rooted in classical technique and musicals built on rock, and each one asks for a different style and a different way of thinking about what you perform.

Why musical theatre came first for Alyssa

Alyssa grew up on show tunes because musical theatre was the most accessible music around her. She only met opera when she started voice lessons. She arrived wanting to be a pop singer, and her teacher had her take a step back and learn classical technique first so she wouldn’t harm her voice along the way. She found real success and enjoyment in it, and from then on she studied both styles side by side.

  • Opera: unamplified, sung over an orchestra, one classical sound
  • Musical theatre: miked, with pop, rock, classical and jazz styles
  • Opera runs are short; a musical can mean eight shows a week for a year
  • Musical theatre adds spoken scenes and, almost always, dance
A singer performing on a large stage under blue lights in front of an audience
Opera and musical theatre both live on stage, but they ask different things of the singer standing there.

Acting: The Training Gap Between Opera and Musical Theatre

Both singers agree that opera singers have to act. The gap is in the training. Musical theatre has real scene work and heavy subject matter, and some shows call for classic techniques such as clown. Alyssa says she never got to dive into those in her opera studies.

Jordanne remembers having to seek out acting classes as electives during her undergraduate degree, sometimes taking a heavier course load to fit them in. Alyssa recalls that in their master’s program, acting work amounted to a rehearsal or two on a scene without singing. Jordanne notes that summer programs with acting and movement training are a fairly recent development for young opera singers.

From standing still to making choices

Alyssa describes the classical habit of standing still in the crook of the piano. Going from that to an opera rehearsal, where you are suddenly expected to follow every impulse, move and take blocking, is a big leap when nothing in your training has shown you how. Jordanne points out that the great opera singers were also great actors, and she names Anna Netrebko, Maria Callas and Sondra Radvanovsky.

  • Take an acting or scene-study class outside your voice lessons
  • Speak your text as a monologue before you sing it
  • Practise your songs while moving, not only standing at the piano
  • Ask what your character wants in every phrase

For more on bringing a song to life in front of an audience, check out this post from the EXPRESS Instagram below!

See the EXPRESS reel on stage presence on Instagram

Permission to Play: Two Training Cultures

The conversation keeps returning to how each world treats mistakes. Jordanne describes classical training as a place where everything is either right or wrong, and mostly wrong for years. Singers become rigid because they are so focused on doing the right thing, and many only love singing again after they leave school.

Alyssa says the attitude in musical theatre might be the biggest difference of all. Crack a note, make the big choice, go all the way, and the team will pull you back: “we would rather you make a mistake than not try.” She also noticed a change in language. In opera she kept hearing that she had potential. In musical theatre the message was closer to “you are talented, let’s take you further.”

Conductors and music directors

Jordanne tells a story from a production of Eugene Onegin. She and her teacher had chosen a chest-heavy approach to a very low role. A voice teacher and the conductor in the room were concerned, and she didn’t feel empowered to say the choice was right for her, even though it felt healthy. Alyssa adds that in her experience the conductor in opera was treated as the final word, while a music director in musical theatre collaborates with the singer on what is comfortable and sustainable. Whatever you decide, she says, you have to be able to do it eight times a week for a year.

  • Agree on a plan for your voice with your teacher, and know why
  • Say “this is the choice I’m making for now” when a coach questions it
  • Stay open to trying another option in rehearsal
  • Judge a choice by whether you can repeat it show after show

Opera vs. Belting: How Each Feels in the Body

Technically, Alyssa says opera always felt like leaning into the top of her range. Her instrument likes chest resonance, which crept in fairly high, and teachers wanted her to keep the sound in head voice. Those notes always felt weaker to her. Musical theatre feels lower and far more grounded in her body. She also says, “my classical training is really what led me to my belt.”

Jordanne understands why classical teachers worry about chest voice: a sound made only of chest resonance won’t carry over an orchestra. She doesn’t believe it harms the voice, though. She says she didn’t learn what a connection to her voice was until she worked on belting and slides with a teacher in New York, with plenty of cracking and odd noises along the way. Her view is that every voice is different, that singers need permission to play with both styles, and that crossover artists show one style doesn’t damage the other.

  • Explore chest voice in short, gentle sessions
  • Use slides between registers and let the voice crack
  • Notice where each style sits in your body
  • Work with a teacher who can hear your voice and explain a plan

For a guided workout to build your chest voice, check out the video below!

Building Your Chest Voice: Workout 1, from the EXPRESS YouTube channel.

Voice Types, Casting and Knowing Your Own Voice

In opera training, Alyssa was told she was a mezzo, a coloratura mezzo and a lyric soprano, depending on who was listening. Some people loved her unusual sound and others told her to fix it. She ended up basing her opinion of herself on whoever was coaching her that week, and she says you lose your sense of self when one person thinks you’re great and the next disagrees.

Musical theatre barely uses voice types. An audition breakdown might ask for a mezzo belter or a soprano with a strong mix, and it will usually give a note range. If you have the notes and the style, you can go for the role.

  • Learn your comfortable range and where your mix and belt sit
  • Read audition breakdowns for the note range, not only the label
  • Record yourself so your opinion of your voice is your own
  • Take what works from each coach and leave the rest

Body Image, Vocal Injury and Favouritism in Voice Training

The middle of the episode covers harder ground. Alyssa expected opera to care only about the voice and was surprised to hear comments about her appearance there too. She says musical theatre is no better: roles written for bigger performers are often the butt of the joke, and romantic leads rarely look like anyone but Hollywood. In her view it is improving, slowly.

They also talk about vocal injury. Alyssa says singers are often made to feel that an injury is their fault or their teacher’s, and that they should hide it for the sake of their career. Jordanne describes how much of a singer’s self-worth is tied to the voice, and why feeling like damaged goods does real harm. Both believe injuries happen to many singers and that the stigma helps no one.

What singers deserve from a school

Both singers saw favouritism in university voice programs, from opposite sides. Jordanne suggests that a voice teacher should check in on a student’s relationship with music and with their own voice, not only on technique. Alyssa makes a simple case for fairness: every student was accepted into the program and pays the same tuition, so each deserves the opportunities that come with it.

  • A teacher who asks how you are, not only how you sound
  • Equal access to masterclasses and performance opportunities
  • Support, not blame, when your voice is injured
  • Room to love more than one style of music
A music teacher performing on stage with a student
A good teacher supports the whole singer, on stage and off.

Opera Auditions vs. Musical Theatre Auditions

The first difference Alyssa names is money. Musical theatre auditions are free, while many opera summer programs charge audition fees, a system she finds predatory because the fees help fund the programs. The repertoire differs too. Opera panels usually want the aria of the character you hope to play. In musical theatre, singing from the show is a faux pas; you choose something similar that proves you can handle the style and shows you at your best.

Callbacks in musical theatre nearly always involve reading a scene with another actor so the team can check chemistry. In opera, Alyssa often met her love interest at the first sing-through. Dress is more relaxed in theatre: look good, and suggest the energy of the character. Unless a show has no dancing at all, expect a dance call that tests whether you can pick up choreography and move with rhythm.

Finding auditions and joining Equity

Alyssa’s biggest source of auditions is word of mouth, followed by Facebook groups for non-union calls, her agent and the Equity E-Drive, an email list of casting calls that she says you can subscribe to without being a member. She booked her first Equity contract after directors saw a video of her singing that her former voice teacher had shared on Facebook. She chose to pay the initiation fee and join right away, and found that membership helped her get seen by bigger theatres.

  • Choose a song in the style of the show, not from the show
  • Prepare a scene for callbacks and be ready to read with a partner
  • Take a beginner dance class so the dance call doesn’t scare you
  • Dress to feel your best and hint at the character
  • Tell your friends when a call goes out; they will do the same for you

For more ways to look and feel confident when you walk into the room, check out the video below!

Look confident on stage: EXPRESS Voice Studio artists share their tips.

Practice, Body Awareness and the Best Singing Advice

With performances cancelled in 2020, Alyssa’s practice turned playful. She sang along with the radio, made up her own riffs, trained her ear to hear “the notes between the notes,” and tested how high she could take her belt and how low her range would go. Jordanne loves that the practice is all questions and no pressure to hit a certain note today.

The best advice Alyssa ever received was “just sing it.” She calls herself a cerebral technician who became robotic trying to avoid being told she was wrong. A teacher asked her what she would do if she were simply saying the words, and that question joined her singing self and her acting self. Jordanne’s version is to speak the whole sentence until it resonates, find the subtext, then sing without thinking about technique. Not every piece of advice suits every voice: Alyssa recalls being taught to create as much space as possible at the back of the mouth, which gave her a big sound and made her sound far older than 18.

Be a body detective

Both singers want more body awareness in voice training. Jordanne suggests Feldenkrais, yoga or the Alexander Technique, and a simple test: a stretch is fine, pain is not. Alyssa reminds singers that the voice changes from day to day, including across the menstrual cycle, and that not being able to recreate a breakthrough is not always your fault. She recommends a fitness routine and singing on the treadmill, because musical theatre asks you to sing while you move. Jordanne adds lip trills in different positions, and a diary of sleep, food and routine. Alyssa’s closing belief is that “singing is your birthright.”

  • Keep a short diary of sleep, food, exercise and how your voice feels
  • Try lip trills sitting, standing and in a stretch
  • Sing a verse while walking on a treadmill
  • Speak the text first, then sing it the same way
  • Stop if it hurts

For a guided Alexander Technique breathing practice, check out the video below!

Alexander Technique guided breathing practice, from the EXPRESS YouTube channel.

Listen to the Full Episode

This guide is based on Season 1, Episode 3 of the Singers Tension Podcast, “Opera v. Musical Theatre: Its not just the sound that’s different,” released in December 2020. Prefer to listen? The full 60-minute conversation is below.

About Alyssa Curto

Alyssa Curto is a Canadian mezzo-soprano and musical theatre performer. She holds a Bachelor of Music from the University of Toronto and a Master of Music from the University of Ottawa, and she is an alumna of the Theatre Aquarius summer programme. Her credits include Disney’s Frozen (Theatre Aquarius), Nicola in Kinky Boots, Irene Roth in Crazy for You and Allison in Beehive: The ’60s Musical (Drayton Entertainment), featured vocalist in Girls Just Wanna Have Fun and One Hit Wonders (Stage West Calgary), and Mina in Dracula (Victoria Playhouse Petrolia).

To see Alyssa backstage on an opening night, check out her Instagram post below!

See Alyssa Curto’s post on Instagram

About the host

Jordanne Erichsen is a soprano, vocal coach and Alexander Technique practitioner, and the founder of EXPRESS Voice Studio. She hosts the Singers Tension Podcast, where working singers talk about technique, the body, performance and the music industry. More episode guides: how to practice singing (even on bad days) with Susan Elizabeth Brown, is opera dying? with Andrew Adridge, how to sing jazz with Laura Anglade, how to become an opera singer with Lyndsay Promane and how to become a vocal coach with Jessica Kos-Whicher.

EXPRESS coaches like Jordanne teach private singing lessons in person in Montreal, Toronto, Vancouver, Ottawa and Mississauga, and through online singing lessons anywhere in Canada. Whether you want to build a belt, explore opera as a hobby or sing both, a coach can help you build healthy technique and your own sound.

Ready to explore your voice? Find your EXPRESS teacher, in Montreal, Toronto, Vancouver or online.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between opera and musical theatre?

Opera is sung without amplification over an orchestra, so training centres on building one classical sound. Musical theatre is miked and spans pop, rock, classical and jazz styles, with spoken scenes, dance and eight shows a week. The training culture, the auditions and the way singers are cast are different too.

Is opera harder to sing than musical theatre?

Neither is harder; they ask for different things. Opera demands a voice that carries over an orchestra without a microphone. Musical theatre demands belting and mixing in many styles, nuanced acting and dancing, and the stamina to repeat a show eight times a week.

Can opera singers sing musical theatre?

Yes. Many singers cross over, and classical training can be a strong foundation. Mezzo-soprano Alyssa Curto says her classical training is what led her to her belt. Crossing over means learning a more speech-like, chest-connected sound, and treating acting and movement as equal parts of the job.

Does classical training help you belt?

It can. Classical technique builds breath management and an understanding of resonance, which support a healthy belt. Belting still has to be practised on its own, because it sits lower and more grounded in the body and is positioned differently in the resonance spaces.

How are musical theatre auditions different from opera auditions?

Opera auditions usually ask for an aria from the role and can charge an application fee. Musical theatre auditions are typically free, ask for a song in the style of the show rather than from it, and often include a callback with scene work and a dance call.

Do you need to dance for musical theatre auditions?

Usually, yes. Unless a show has no dancing at all, expect a dance call. Its difficulty depends on the show and the role, and it mostly tests whether you can pick up choreography and move with rhythm.

Full Episode Transcript

This transcript of “Opera v. Musical Theatre: Its not just the sound that’s different” was generated automatically and lightly corrected, so small errors may remain. About 14 minutes of the conversation are not transcribed; the complete conversation is in the episode above.

Read the full transcript

Opera vs. musical theatre: the biggest differences (00:00)

Jordanne: This is the Singers Tension Podcast, the podcast by singers for singers. Okay, so I’m here today with Alyssa Curto, who is an amazing, beautiful performer of musical theatre. She was trained in opera at the University of Toronto and University of Ottawa and in the last few years has worked professionally in musical theatre in Toronto, Canada. So welcome Alyssa to the Singers Tension Podcast. Thank you so much. Thank you for having me. So today we’re going to kind of dive into the operatic world versus the musical theatre world. So versatility as a performer cannot be undervalued. The more versatile you are as a singer, actor, performer, the more opportunities you have for employment and training for a career in opera. You hear this all the time. branch out, learn how to do musical theatre and opera. There isn’t enough opera opportunity in Canada to just hold out for the big roles and make it living. You hear this all the time and certainly singing opera is a lifetime in depth. equatable to an Olympic athlete. And I think that perhaps classical singers can be naive in their assumption that opera is the more challenging art form, which I don’t necessarily believe is true. I mean, if you look at musical theatre, it demands acting skills that are as nuanced as stage actors, which sometimes can be overlooked in opera where the weight of the importance falls heavily on the voice. And then again, in musical theatre, belting is very different from opera and it’s positioning in your resonance spaces, which also requires practice to build endurance to do this night after night after night, something that opera singers don’t normally have, you know, 60 performances in a row. And where opera must be heard over large orchestras and musical theatre is miked. And so performers can play with intensity, emotion and colour in completely different ways. So I want to know, Alyssa, what do you perceive instantly as the biggest difference between musical theatre form and operatic theatre form? And tell us a little bit about your journey of learning the two styles.

Alyssa: Yeah, that’s a great question. So, I mean, it’s difficult to really just pinpoint one major difference because, I mean, both art forms are really so beautiful and they have their own, you know, unique elements to them. But I think, you know, for me, the main difference and why I love musical theater, I have to say more than I did opera, is just the versatility within the art form itself. You know, you have like musicals that are based on pop music and musicals that are based in more classical technique and musicals that are based in rock and musical, like all genres of music are pretty much represented in musical theater. And they all require different style and different technique and different thought into what you’re performing. I think, too, the biggest difference that I found, similar to what you were mentioning, is the acting aspect of it, too. Because it’s not that you don’t have to act in opera. We know that that’s not the case, even though that might have been maybe the performance practice of the olden times. It’s definitely not the… the current trend. But you know you have actual scene work in musical theater and there’s you know some really heavy topics that they talk about but there’s also you know shows and characters that are are based in these like uh like more classic acting styles like you have to know clown technique for some of them you have to know um you know different Lecoq theories or what all of those those things that you really don’t get to dive into as much in your study of acting as an opera singer. or at least I didn’t in my experience. So for me, growing up, I gravitated to musical theater because it was what was the most accessible to me. And I had friends that we would listen to show tunes together, we would dive into different musicals. And so I didn’t really actually get exposed to opera until I started training. And I came in being like, I’m going to be the best pop singer in the world. And my vocal teacher was like, let’s take a step back. and make sure that you don’t ruin your voice in the process of that journey. And so we started working on more classical pieces and I learned the classical technique and I found that I did have a lot of success with that and I got enjoyment out of that and I will always say that my classical training is really what led me to my belt. And so I almost simultaneously studied both styles and got to figure out the differences between them. There are some that are subtle and there are some that are very obvious but yeah, and I I think that that really led to My sort of double life that I ended up leading in school.

Acting training and permission to play (05:00)

Jordanne: I remember because we did our master’s degrees together and I remember watching a clip of you singing musical theater from like years before when you were just a wee baby and you were already so good like it just was a style that fit you and I think What is sad about opera is that when you go to university for it, it’s not built into, at least not the Canadian universities in the programs, to have acting training. When I was in my undergrad, I specifically had to seek out those classes as electives. and in some cases take on a heavier course load so that I could have those classes because I thought it was a crucial part and I wasn’t seeing a lot of people around me really putting the emphasis on the acting which never made sense to me because it’s a story but in musical theatre obviously you’re being trained in acting and how to do transferences and pulling on your emotions but in opera you look at the students in there on this trajectory of how do I build the voice, the voice, the voice, the voice. But the most amazing opera singers, you think of Anna Netrebko naturally was such a great actress, but

Alyssa: Callas too.

Jordanne: Oh yeah, Callas too. And Sondra Radvanovsky was trained in acting as well and she’s one of the greatest singers of our generation. So to me, this shouldn’t be a difference between the two styles and yet it still is and it’s something that I know the opera community today is trying to push against and put more of an emphasis on acting by sending young singers to summer programs where there is acting training and body movement training but that’s actually quite a recent development.

Alyssa: Yeah I remember in our master’s degrees like we we did have a couple very very basic acting classes that I mean they weren’t they weren’t even really separate classes it was just when you were doing the opera within the context of the degree there would be like maybe one or two rehearsals where we would be working on a scene is from just an acting standpoint without singing and that was pretty much all that it was which relies really heavily on your you know actors instincts quote-unquote but you don’t always have those especially if you’ve been really conditioned to this sort of unfortunate That’s the right word unfortunate just attitude of like when you’re in a classical setting you have to be rigid by the piano just in that crook and you don’t move and you just keep everything really still so it’s very difficult to go from that to an all of a sudden whatever your impulses are you should do them, you know, so it’s A little bit unreasonable. I think that some of the things we expect the young singers to just naturally be comfortable with go from a very rigid concert setting to now you’re in an opera and all of a sudden you have to move and make choices and do blocking and you just need to figure it out because you have nothing there really to guide you or to tell you what you should be doing.

Jordanne: Yes and especially as young singers when you’re in that world of classical music everything is either right or it’s wrong and it’s going to be wrong wrong wrong wrong for most of your life unless you’re one of these very few people. that woke up and after four years of university, you know, they’re singing at the med. That’s not the norm. That’s a very rare case. And so you as a person trying to build your voice, if it’s wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, you become rigid because you’re so focused on just doing the right thing. And that’s also why a lot of classical singers get into a space where they… They’re like, wow, I didn’t really love singing again until I was out of school. Because when you don’t have people telling you it’s wrong all the time, you open yourself up to play more. And you never really feel ready to perform and put yourself out there in classical music because you always think it’s wrong and you see how much farther you have to go in comparison to, you know, those people on the big stages. And in musical theatre, it’s Just more permission to make weird choices.

Alyssa: 100%. And I was just going to say, like, I think that might actually be the biggest difference that I’ve noticed is that the culture and the environment is crack a note, you know, like, sound terrible. Do the stupidest thing and go all the way and make it big and we will pull you back. And that is the attitude. It’s just like, we would rather you make a mistake than not try. And your technique lessons are never, you know, these are all like, there’s that word, that buzzword that I mean, that I always got the, you know, potential, potential, you have potential, you have potential. That’s not the attitude in musical theater. It’s yes, I mean, they recognize talent and they let you know when you need to work on something further. But the attitude is more like you are talented, let’s take you further. Not you have the potential to be talented. You know what I mean?

Trusting your own voice with teachers and conductors (10:00)

Jordanne: Yeah. especially if you are in the classical world and you’re starting to perform, it’s so important to have a really good teacher that not only is helping you to improve as a singer, but understands how to communicate with you, where they hear your voice now, what the path looks like ahead for you, so that when you go in and you perform or you practice something in front of a coach or a conductor and they say, Oh, I don’t think that that’s good for your voice, the way you’re singing that. You feel empowered to say, actually, my teacher and I know that this is the right path. This is how I’m going to sing it for now. It’s the choice that I’m making. And to be confident in that choice. I remember when I was doing Eugene Onegin with Nuova in one of the rehearsals. that it’s a very low role and so my teacher and I had been listening to some incredible singers from you know early eras and how when they went to a really low note they really got quite chesty about it before it went to a high note as if they were anchoring it down so that it didn’t come into their throat so I made the choice to sing it like this and I remember the voice teacher in the room and the conductor were like not expecting this chest and actually were legitimately concerned for my voice when we took a pause I said no no no it’s it’s way too much chest But looking back on it now, it was a few years ago, it was 100% the right way to do it for me at the time. It felt healthy. But I didn’t feel empowered to say, that’s right for me. Because when people are telling you it’s wrong, and they’re the ones that have the careers and are much further ahead in their careers than you, you just feel like you should listen. But you know your body. You know your body. So there needs to be a fine balance, and that’s hard to find. but it seems even more important in opera, whereas musical theater, I feel like the conductor or director would just say, I don’t know about that choice, could we play with it? But you could justify your choice and they would be open to it.

Alyssa: A hundred percent. I mean the conductor or music director to singer dynamic is also very different from musical theater to opera. Mostly in that, in my experience you know you’re Conductor was always like God in opera. Whatever they said was what it had to be. And a music director in musical theater is very focused on collaborating with you and going to you first, deferring to you and your choices and what’s comfortable for you and what’s sustainable for you. Because again, you have to take into consideration that whatever decisions you’re making, you have to be able to do eight times a week for a year.

How opera and belting feel in the body (13:00)

Jordanne: That’s it. So true. So for you, when you think about the way opera feels in your body versus musical theatre, what do you feel are the biggest technical differences there?

Alyssa: Well, that’s a good question. It’s hard to define because my theories on placement and you know, register changes have sort of evolved over the years and they’re different now than what they were when I was in school. But if I take myself back to trying to learn those two styles simultaneously, I mean, I would say the biggest, you know, technical and physical difference for me in my body was just that opera always felt I had to really lean in to the top of my range because those were the notes that I was the most successful in. Again, because my voice, my instrument really likes to add chest. I feel very comfortable grounding myself in my chest resonance and it would come through. Pretty high for opera, you know, like I I would say maybe even at like f4 g4 It would still be creeping in and that was comfortable for me And I felt I needed to do that in order to get the note out in the best way and as you said You know like that none of my teachers were very into that so I would try to like force it into this opera sound And keep it in my head voice as much as I could but then those notes always felt like weaker. So if I had to qualify it I think I would say like opera you know felt like my weaker side of my voice and musical theater feels so much just lower and so much more grounded in my body.

Jordanne: Yeah I understand the fear that a lot of classical teachers have of their students using too much chest more so from the perspective of if you are singing only using your chest resonance it won’t carry over the orchestra but I don’t believe that it would hurt your sound and I really didn’t learn what what a connection to my voice was until I worked with Michael Warren in New York and we worked on belting and lots of slides and then finding that connection through the chest voice and allowing things to you know there’s lots of cracking lots of weird noises but basically figuring out what does it mean to always feel like I’m singing from my body even on those highest notes so I understand the fear from carrying over the orchestra way, but not from a hurting your voice way. And that’s always kind of a tricky subject with opera singing teachers, but every voice is different. So if you got a voice and you were teaching them how to sing opera, but they had no connection to their chest and you started talking about placement in your nasal cavities and the resonance through your head. most likely they’re going to try to place their sound there and use their throat because they don’t have an anchor. But that could work really well for someone who had a really big voice and it was sitting quite low, but they were just missing overtones. So I think just teaching these two styles in general, there needs to be like permission to play with both styles. There are a lot of crossover artists like we’ll talk about. So obviously these people aren’t hurting their operatic voice because they’re singing musical theater.

Voice types and casting (17:00)

Alyssa: Right, completely. And I mean, I think, you know, to be completely fair, I think a lot of the issues that I had with that stemmed from the fact that nobody really knew in the opera world what to do with my voice necessarily. Like to put it in perspective, I was really quite often compared to Maria Callas in that my voice was weird it just like didn’t always sound pretty and conventionally operatic and there were people who you know loved that and were like oh it’s a unique sound and then there were people who were like it sounds ugly you should probably work on your technique more and you know i had people saying you’re a mezzo you’re a coloratura mezzo and then other people being like no you’re a lyric soprano and so throughout my whole you know journey of training I just never got to settle into any anything so I was just constantly you know basing my opinion of myself on whoever I was talking to at the time and whoever I was being coached by at the time because everybody had a different opinion so I could never rely on you just you know you lose your sense of self when everybody’s telling you one person thinks you’re great and the other person thinks you’re crap and you just have to kind of truck through and try to take what works and discard the rest but you don’t even know what’s working because the next person you talk to doesn’t think that it’s working so you have to discard that and try something else and it was just a very uh you know it’s just a very confusing time and musical theater i never had that issue because i think just naturally my instrument was right for it

Jordanne: Mm-hmm. Do you find that in general there’s just not as strict of a classification of your voice is this so you can only sing this repertoire?

Alyssa: Oh yes, a hundred percent. There’s no, like voice type is really hardly ever used. I mean, there are, if you see like a breakdown of an audition, they’ll say, you know, we want a mezzo belter or we want, or they’ll say we want a soprano with a strong mix. Like it’s It really doesn’t matter though because if I see that and I know that I’m a singer with a strong mix I can go for that role. They’ll usually give a note range so they’ll say something like we want E3 to E5 and if you have those notes then you’re good and that’s really all they care about.

[About 14 minutes of the conversation, on body image, vocal injury, mental health and favouritism in voice training, are not transcribed here. Listen to the full episode above to hear that part.]

Opera auditions vs. musical theatre auditions (33:00)

Jordanne: When you went out into the real world, what was the difference between opera auditions versus musical theater auditions for you?

Alyssa: Well, I mean, for one, you don’t have to pay for musical theater auditions, which was, you know, a huge thing. And I mean, again, I have very strong opinions on the audition process in opera versus musical theater, mainly that I find the opera system to be predatory in a way. because you know a lot of these summer programs or pay to sings or whatever you want to call them they use that audition money to fund their own program so in a sense they they often use the people trying to make a career in this to keep the the art form sustained and i don’t i don’t think that that’s appropriate i think like i said i think it’s predatory um but in terms of aside from the money you know a musical theater audition is very different than an opera audition especially in that usually in an opera audition they want you to sing something from the show that you’re auditioning for usually they want you to sing the aria that you are of the character you are trying to book whereas in musical theater that’s sort of a faux pas you really don’t want to actually do any rep from the show you want to pick something that’s similar that shows that you can do the style, that you can handle the genre of music, and that shows you off in your best. And then there’s often, you know, you’ll be asked to go to a callback in musical theater, like pretty much all the time, unless, you know, you get cut at the initial audition. And in that callback, you’ll always be with someone else running a scene together, just so that they can see whose chemistry works. better with other people. And I mean, you really don’t find that, at least in my experience, I didn’t find that in opera at all. So oftentimes, if you did book a job, you know, you’d be meeting your love interest for the first time at the first sing-through, which is always a little bit like, ah! Whereas in musical theater, I think they do take more time to allow you to create those friendships with people before you have to like go on stage and kiss them.

Jordanne: Yeah, it’s happened very rarely for me with opera, but sometimes they will do a table talk, which is always used with acting performances, stage acting, to talk through the motives of the characters, the main themes, the director’s vision. But that, like I said, that’s only been in rare cases for opera. And as you said, it’s hello, we’re in love. So then your acting is really tested. Yep. Yep. And in terms of attire between the two auditions, I know opera audition singers are kind of, not business casual, maybe business casual is too light. It would be more like a cocktail party kind of a tie.

Alyssa: Yeah, yeah. Definitely more semi-formal, much more formal than a musical theater audition. Usually in theater, like, they want you to dress nice, but I’ve definitely done auditions in jeans, and it’s not looked at with any sort of… side eye. You just want to emulate the energy and the style of the character that you are auditioning for and in the case of a general audition you just want to go in looking bomb. So whatever makes you feel the best is what you wear.

Jordanne: Do you come across dance being necessary in a lot of these auditions or are you noticing things are more acting directed and so dance has become less important?

Alyssa: It definitely depends on the show. So, you know, if you’re going for a show like Spring Awakening or what other ones aren’t that dance heavy? I mean, honestly, even something like Beauty and the Beast or some of the Disney shows where the character that you are likely going to play isn’t one of the big dance roles, then it’s not as important. I wouldn’t say that it’s not still significant because no matter what… Unless it’s a show that absolutely has no dancing in it whatsoever You will do a dance call which can just will vary in you know level of difficulty It’s basically like can you pick up choreography and can you move with rhythm and do you look like a fool doing so? You know, so I would say that dance is still something that you need to have But you don’t have to be like Baryshnikov by any means, especially if your hit is not major dance roles.

Finding auditions and joining Equity (38:00)

Jordanne: For someone looking to start going to these auditions, where do you pull your listings from? How do you find out about them?

Alyssa: My biggest source is honestly word of mouth. So I have a lot of friends that are also trying to make careers in the industry. And I mean, we don’t have that kind of competitive or catty nature. So if there’s a call going out, a lot of people will be like, I’m going to it. You know, you should come. or I’ll peruse Facebook. There’s lots of groups that post for non-union calls. But I mean, now that I am union, I do have an agent. So a lot of the stuff that I get asked to audition for does come through her. But I, oh, I do subscribe to the Equity E-Drive, which you do not have to be an equity member to subscribe to. So it’s definitely, it’s something I recommend to everybody. And they put, It’s just an email list essentially that emails you every time there’s an audition call or a job posting, anything arts related. And in the email we’ll have the entire breakdown of the casting call. We will tell you what you need to send in, who to send it to, who to address it to, all of the good stuff. So that’s definitely been an invaluable resource for sure.

Jordanne: So you just became a member of equity right and what was that process? When do you think it’s a good time for a singer to consider joining?

Alyssa: So I mean my story is a little bit unique with it because essentially what happened was I actually got this job Through a video I had posted on Facebook Yeah, I had shared this video of me singing someday from hunchback like the show clip and My old voice teacher had shared it on Facebook and I guess he knows the two directors at Victoria Playhouse who watched the video and were like, we need to have the scroll come in for an audition. Which felt amazing for me because very rarely do you get opportunities like that, to be honest. So I went in and did the audition and everything was great and they had a really good time. They were lovely. They coached me through everything and it was a lengthy audition. I would say that for an initial audition, I was in there for like half an hour, which is fairly long. But I left feeling really good and they called my voice teacher and were like, you know, do you think she can handle like a full run? And he was like, she’s done a lot of musical theater. I think she’ll be fine. So they gave me the job and it was my first equity house job that I had booked. So I mean equity is a little easier to get into than ACTRA, which is the film union. So equity, you only need one credit to essentially be able to buy in. So when you get your equity credit, you have a choice. You can either hold off and just have a equity permit for the length of the contract which then you know goes away as soon as the contract is up and you can wait until your third equity credit by which point you have to join but because you’ve been paying dues in your permits up to the third you have no initiation fee or it’s like next to nothing or you can go right in right away and pay the initiation fee which is about just over a thousand dollars so there’s there’s kind of two schools of thought on whether you should wait or whether you shouldn’t wait. But because it had happened for me a little bit later in my career than some of my colleagues. And again, purely because I had taken that six year detour in opera. So I wasn’t that Sheridan grad who graduated at 21 and was working right away through all the networking that I had done at school. I really felt for me, this is, I don’t know when my next equity job is coming. but I feel like having equity attached to my name and being a union member is going to get me into much more equity rooms than not being that. So I chose to just go in with the initiation fee. I paid it and I became a full member and I still am to this day. And then kind of right after that, I started getting called in to audition for the other bigger houses like Port Hope and Drayton. And again, I think it’s because I’m a union member and I think that lends a lot of credibility to my name. And then I booked my next equity gig, which ended up being canceled due to COVID. But it started to snowball for sure.

Jordanne: Yeah, I think it’s such a personal choice. You have to be honest with yourself of where is your voice at and you as an artist and performer and Also your finances as soon as you are part of equity You have to ask permission to take non equity gigs, right?

Alyssa: They are yes, but they are very Lenient with that like I have done some non-union work since joining and it has never been an issue

Practising without a gig on the calendar (43:00)

Jordanne: Oh that’s amazing and a lot of your gigs were cancelled this year because of COVID like what does that look like for you with your career this year?

Alyssa: Well so I mean my performance career is still very varied uh so I have you know musical theatre things on the go I also sing with a cover band and we do a lot of corporate events and a lot of big festivals and those all got put on hold as well uh so I mean I had some things lined up pretty much till the end of the year that all kind of got washed away in one fell swoop.

Jordanne: And what do you feel like your attitude as a performer that needs to practice is? Like how are you going about practicing even though there’s nothing specific lined up in the future? Do you feel that weighs on you?

Alyssa: You know what I’m such a bad singer in this way that I’m not a huge, like I don’t practice every day. But I think for me, again, this is another major difference between musical theater and opera, that in my personal journey, my musical theater technique and my knowledge of my instrument, my understanding of my instrument and my ability to control my own instrument is already pretty much where it needs to be. I pride myself on the fact that when it comes to musical theater and pop and rock and jazz, all of those genres, I can sing it all. And so when it comes to practicing, the practice comes more from figuring out how to basically stretch myself into the best. version of my voice and what like pushing the limits, you know, like doing the whole Elsa like test the limits and break through like just Figuring out what how far can I take that before it? I reached my limit. Yeah, so I’m right now I’m practicing more on my inner ear so I’m you know, I’m singing along with the radio and I’m riffing and I’m trying to make up my own riffs and I’m trying to get really good at hearing the notes between the notes and flexing that improvisatory style because those are the kinds of things that I practice now those are those are the kinds of things that I do to stretch right like so my my riffing capabilities they’re pretty basic right now how can I make them better or you know how high can I take that belt tone before it becomes unnecessary or you know um what are what’s my low range looking like right now what how many roles can I sing that are still really deep in the basement what a what can I explore that isn’t something that someone would look at me and think I could sing.

Jordanne: Yeah, I just like so much that the way you’ve described it is so playful. It’s just a bunch of questions and thoughts of maybe I’ll try this and maybe I’ll try that and perhaps this could be something in the future but not putting pressure on yourself that today I will hit this note.

Alyssa: Yes, completely.

The best and worst singing advice (46:00)

Jordanne: So in your career, whether it was through the opera training or musical theatre, any of the teachers you’ve ever had, what’s the best singing advice you’ve ever gotten?

Alyssa: You’re going to laugh because it’s literally, just sing it. I find that when you’re a cerebral technician, you tend to get really in your head about every minute detail of what you’re doing, and especially when you’re expecting that someone’s going to say it’s wrong. I think I had such a bad internal headspace of like whatever I was putting out was gonna be not liked by somebody so I just had to focus on making everything perfect because I didn’t want to have anybody say anything about it and you know what you sacrifice when you do that is is the story is the communication is expression is creativity so you know I had one teacher who was just you know I won’t use the exact words but you know just insert expletive here sing it and what are you trying to say and I think at one point he even said like can you just act like a human being because I was definitely getting very robotic in the way that I would approach things and he was just like what would you do if you were actually just saying that like let’s pretend that you didn’t need to sing it and you were just telling me what the heck would you do what would you say how would you say it sing it like that and it was revolutionary for me because I had always had this sort of separation of acting while singing and acting, if that makes sense. Like there was definitely a divorce between like, this is my singing self and this is my acting self. And I hadn’t, I didn’t know that you could be both. And so once I figured that out, it made, I mean, I sang it so much better because I just didn’t, I just didn’t care and I let myself go and I focused on communicating what I was supposed to be communicating with the song rather than just trying not to get told that something I was doing was wrong.

Jordanne: I really believe that when you read music perhaps you’re at a disadvantage because you see the notes on the page and you see oh this is an interval of a 12th and thus I must prepare the body you know you learn music note to note to note playing it on the piano and you disassociate from what you’re actually saying so one exercise I always liked was to say even if the sentence goes on for three or four pages and which can happen in opera to say it to yourself the whole sentence until it resonates with you and figure out what are your motivations here what’s your subtext can you play with thinking about that subtext while you’re singing and just not think about the technique at all what happens and to make it again playful to me that’s It doesn’t make any sense to sing something and not have an idea of the story you’re trying to tell and who the person is, but we do that. We learn the music, so we’re like, I sing this perfectly now, and you lose sight of the person that is so supposed to be singing it.

Alyssa: Completely.

Jordanne: So that’s best advice. Now, have you ever given advice, I’m not saying it’s bad advice, but advice that didn’t work for you as a singer because I always talk about how every teacher explains things differently. You need to find a teacher that you connect with how they’re explaining it. And the best teachers always can look at your body and what you’re doing and creates a process that works for you. But you’re going to come across teachers that give you something that doesn’t work.

Alyssa: Totally. Okay, so something that really didn’t work for me, this is going back into again opera training, but I had a teacher, you know, who in her own rights was a wonderful singer, like lovely. But she had this idea, I think that she really, I mean we talk about raising the palette and really opening up space in the back of the head and all those good things, but she I think would just take it to the extreme. Like she kind of had that I don’t know if you’ve ever seen this masterclass by Cecilia Bartoli where she just talks about like forcibly lowering her larynx Where she like you can actually like see it moving down in this video But she would kind of I mean it wasn’t that exaggerated, but she was really trying to like make this cavern Happen in the back like regardless of a singer’s physiology like didn’t matter what the anatomy she just wanted like you better stretch girl and just like make it as much space between larynx and soft palate as possible. Which you know had its advantages at the time because I was able to create this like huge like big opera singer sound. But I realized after that I was like 18 and I sounded like an old woman. Like I sounded like her. And you know she kind of went to have this magic effect on her her students that they would stop sounding like young opera singers and they would sound like that. Like you know I don’t even know what the right you know, maybe like Franny at the end of her life, you know, like it would just, it would be like way, way exaggerated. Sort of, probably more like what you think an opera singer sounds like in your head as someone who’s never heard opera.

Jordanne: And it’s just so hard with singing because that might be the exact thing that someone needs to make them surreal amazing, but then for you it didn’t work. So it’s…

Alyssa: I mean I know singers that worked with her that that works wonderfully for and you know they have they just have different voices in different colors in mine but yeah I mean I have a low speaking voice but you know my singing voice is very Disney princess it just is and I have low notes too but when it comes to that like operatic sound or the classical sound like my higher notes are where I like to live and I definitely I definitely had some heavy, heavy color when working with her for sure.

Body awareness for singers (52:00)

Jordanne: And if someone is a newbie singer and they’re looking for a teacher, it does come back to that idea of… being confident in what your sensations are in your body, but at the beginning, you don’t really know what you’re supposed to be feeling and what your body is. So I think it’s important to try different teachers, hear what they’re saying, play with things, and also do some kind of body awareness where, whether it’s Feldenkrais or yoga or Alexander technique, just to pay attention to where am I feeling tension today versus four weeks ago. Do I think it’s better? Is it more painful to sing? A great barometer is if it feels painful, it’s probably not right. But if it just feels kind of like a stretch, like, you know, if you’re doing yoga and you really stress something out, okay, that just might be something shifting. But if you’re singing two lines and it feels like someone has their hand around your throat, most likely it’s not working for you. I’m just taking a guess.

Alyssa: I mean, yeah, like you said, you know, I think that there could be so much more emphasis on body awareness. And there’s so many things that, you know, they don’t even tell you when you start training. Like, you know, just because of my experiences as a woman, like you don’t even know, like there’s differences would, depending on what point in your cycle you’re at, will affect things in your voice and your intentions on any given day. And I remember teachers telling me, you know, especially when I was younger, and honestly, It’s sort of leveled out now, but I would say that probably didn’t even really happen until I was like 25 or 26. But they were like, you’re going to have days where your voice just does not do what you want it to do. And there might be nothing you can do about that in the moment. You just have to try and navigate it, ride the wave and say, it’s going to be better tomorrow when my body isn’t what it is today. And that was, you know, it’s I think we need to give singers more permission to. excuse themselves with that and have compassion for themselves because you don’t enter into every day at the exact same place you were the day before. And you’re not always in the same place physically that you were when you had that breakthrough in your lesson. So if you can’t always recreate it, it’s not even necessarily always your fault. There’s a million factors that could be playing into that.

Jordanne: That speaks to the importance, if you want to be a singer and an artist, someone who uses their body for their profession, you really do have to have this unprecedented commitment, like an Olympic athlete, where you watch, what am I eating? What’s my routine? How much sleep am I getting? Did I stop doing stretching this week? You have to be a body detective and figure out what you need for your instrument and your lifestyle and your routine, and then make choices based on that. I know a lot of singers that are women, that when their time of the month comes, they find it really heavy, really hard to sing in their throat, in their cords, and other singers are not affected by it at all. So if you weren’t paying attention to your body, you’re like, why do sometimes I just can’t feel like I can sing? but you have no idea that actually it’s related to your period, but it’s actually a thing. You have to pay attention. I think it’s a good idea to keep a diary for like a few months and change up your routine every couple of weeks, like, okay, now I’m going to try getting nine hours of sleep or now I’m going to try meditating 15 minutes before I practice and know what you’re feeling, what that did for you. Nobody can answer those questions but you.

Alyssa: Yeah, and I mean, I always recommend that, you know, I think every singer and every you know, anyone who plans to be on stage should have some sort of exercise regimen that they follow, especially if you’re going to do musical theater. But yeah, it’s like an instant key into your body and I didn’t even really know until I started getting more into fitness exactly what I was missing on that awareness and how much I wasn’t in tune with what was going on internally.

Jordanne: Diet and exercise if not just for the focus you know you’re able to really be in the moment and focus in more on what you’re doing plus energy you don’t need those naps anymore and when you’re singing you’re standing up usually in one position you’re super hyper focused When you’re on stage, you need to be malleable like the blob monster. You have to be able to do everything and anything with your body and sing in those positions. So when you’re working out, especially yoga or if you’re lifting weights but not too heavy, to pay attention to what your breath is doing. And can you do lip trills while you are in these different positions? Do you feel all of a sudden, oh, I’m sitting down and now my breath feels really stuck in my chest? That’s a huge red flag. Obviously, something’s happening when you sit down that’s collapsing your apparatus. So you need to figure that out because when you go on stage, if you have this epic moment and the director says, you’re really sad, you need to sit down, and you can’t sing it because you’ve only ever sung standing up. Uh-oh.

Alyssa: Yeah. I mean, I’ll always tell every singer to sing while you’re on the treadmill. Because I mean, in musical theater, there are so many moments where you have to sing while doing these crazy dance moves. And there are some things that get prerecorded, but it’s never solo. It’s only ever if you sweeten tracks sometimes with prerecording the chorus so it sounds fuller. But I mean, I’ve seen productions. There’s a production show called Well, a show, SpongeBob SquarePants, the musical. And he literally has to sing while climbing up this, like, apparatus. And at one point, he, like, sings this, belts this high note while his abdomen is literally supporting him on, like, a monkey bar-style, like, structure. And he has to just, like… I think it’s even something crazy. It might even be, like, an A. Like, it’s insane. I don’t know how he trained for that, but it’s, you know… They ask a lot of you and your body… especially in musical theater. So it’s something to keep in mind for sure.

Singing is your birthright (58:00)

Jordanne: He probably just trained by planking everywhere and singing high notes. Okay, last question. What is something you believe about the voice? Profoundly believe, doesn’t have to be technique related, but speaks to you.

Alyssa: I profoundly believe that singing is your birthright. and that whether or not you feel that you can, you should because there is just something. Singing is what happens when you can no longer speak but you still need to vocally express.

Jordanne: I like that. Thank you so much, Alyssa, for joining me on the Singers Tension Podcast. It’s such a pleasure.

Alyssa: It was such a pleasure to talk to you.

Sources

The Newsletter.

Stay in the Loop:

-> Find out when new artists are available to take lessons with.

-> Learn about local performance opportunities

-> Be first to register for concerts and classes

More Tips

Acting for Singers: How to Connect With a Character on Stage

Acting for singers: how to trust your instincts, build a character and let go on stage, with operatic tenor, composer and actor River Guard.
Read More
Singer in a red blouse singing into a microphone at an Express Voice Studio show

How to Sing Jazz: Advice From JUNO Winner Laura Anglade

How to sing jazz, from JUNO-winning vocalist Laura Anglade: learn the language by transcribing, scat, phrase off the beat and own the stage.
Read More
Shyla Gray, professeure de chant R&B à Mississauga

EXPRESS Launches in Mississauga: A Music School of Working Artists

EXPRESS Voice Studio launches in Mississauga: private singing, songwriting, music production, drum and piano lessons with working artists near Square One.
Read More
Lauren Margison singing teacher

Is Opera Dying? Diversity, Community and the Future of Opera

Is opera dying? Opera InReach co-founder Andrew Adridge on diversity, mentorship for young singers and how opera can belong to everyone.
Read More
Front view of a vocal coach singing opera. Singing lessons Ndg.

How to Become an Opera Singer: Life After Music School

How to become an opera singer after music school: YAPs, auditions, paying the bills and a portfolio career, with mezzo-soprano Lyndsay Promane.
Read More
Professeur de musique avec un élève

How to Become a Vocal Coach and Start Your Own Studio

How to become a vocal coach and launch a voice studio: branding, finding students, hiring teachers and imposter syndrome, with soprano Jessica Kos-Whicher.
Read More